Let’s Call It What It Is!

It’s always kind of shocking to me just how easily I can rename my actions to make them more acceptable. When it comes to my failures, I so easily spiritualize them or turn them into “mistakes.”

What do I mean?

I call gossip prayer requests. I call laziness a lack of motivation. I rationalize my anger by renaming it “a bad day.”

And, perhaps most often for myself, I soften what is truly worry and anxiety by calling it overthinking. In fact, I’ve called myself an overthinker for so long that my friends and family describe me that way, too.

Overthinker… such a gentle and acceptable term for what the Bible simply calls worry and anxiety. When I’m just an overthinker, I can make jokes about my social anxiety, justify my continual plan changes, and excuse away my what-if thinking. I can even make others wonder if they’re just not as equipped as I am to solve problems and figure out the best plan to follow.

Well-honed overthinking sounds like I’m really smart. Constant anxiety sounds like I’m really unspiritual.

Unfortunately, no matter what I call it, my overthinking isn’t acceptable to God. In fact, the Scriptures make it clear that continuing to worry and allowing anxiety in my life is nothing more than a heart idol… Nothing less than sin.

In Philippians 4:6, the Apostle Paul commands (doesn’t suggest), “Be anxious for nothing, but in everything by prayer and supplication, with thanksgiving, let your request be made known to God.”

In Matthew 6, our Lord Jesus says twice, “Do not worry.” Interestingly, He doesn’t add any escape clauses when worry is our only choice.

I know these commands. I’ve read them, studied them, and meditated on them. Yet, I still lean on my redefinition of  anxiety by calling it “overthinking.” When I do this, James 4:17 is a stark reminder: “He who knows the right thing to do and does not do it, for him it is sin.” OUCH!

I don’t believe that I’m the only one who struggles with this seesaw of overthinking and anxiety. But if overthinking truly is sin, what are we to do?

The first step is recognizing that we disobey God when we slip into the worry-and-anxiety loop. Worry and anxiety “lean on our own understanding” (Proverbs 3:5), robbing God of the opportunity to lead our lives. When I overthink, I’m really trying to control the outcomes in my life. The beautiful name of God, Adonai, reminds me that God alone is my Lord and Master. As such, He is the only One who controls those outcomes. Trying to control my own life is a choice to hold God at arm’s length. When I do so, I elevate my perceived wisdom over His right to lead me. Because of that, the only right response to my continual worrying is repentance and confession.

NEWS FLASH! God is better at controlling our outcomes than we are!

What does overthinking look like for you? For me, it’s the heart-pounding nervousness that I feel before I walk into a social situation. It’s working and reworking every plan to make sure nothing could possibly go wrong. It’s continually seeking reassurance that I am not too much or too little in other people’s eyes. It’s wondering if I’m really just kind of annoying.

2 Corinthians 10:5 says that we are to “take every thought captive to make it obedient to Christ.”

That means that we must apply truth to all of those “overthinking thoughts!” to make them align with what Christ says is true.

Truth reminds me that people actually enjoy spending time with me. They even invite me to things! It doesn’t rewrite my social interactions; instead, it allows me to be fully present and not self-conscious.

Truth reminds me that, of course, things might go wrong! But it also jogs my mind and encourages me that some of the best memories came about during those wrong times.

Truth dispels my not-enough or too-much feelings and replaces them with truths from God’s Word. Truthful reminders like: I am a child of God. (1 John 3:1) I am a new creation. (2 Corinthians 5:17) I am fearfully and wonderfully made. (Psalm 139:14)

And so many, many more…

Truth is the solution to anxiety and worry. We have a God who loves us (so much that He sent His only Son to die for us!), and we can trust Him.

Anxiety, even when it’s hidden in the shadows of the culturally acceptable word overthinker, robs us of the ability to walk in peace. It is no small thing, affecting our hearts, our minds, and our health. It robs us of our joy and can even disrupt our relationships. (Why didn’t he send with a heart emoji like he usually does? … Been there? I sure have!)

Often, the best thing we can do for our hearts is to ask God to examine them carefully. Ask Him if we are rationalizing our worry and anxiety by giving it an acceptable name as a substitute for what it really is.

Philippians 4:6 commands us to abandon our anxiety, but Philippians 4:7 gives us the reassuring “Why?”

“And the peace of God, which surpasses all comprehension, will guard your hearts and minds in Christ Jesus.” I don’t know about you, but the peace of God sounds way better than any overthinking I could do!